Spare Tire Subwoofer vs Underseat Subwoofer

Are you looking for a powerful subwoofer to boost your car audio system? If yes, then you must be thinking about the two most popular types of subwoofers: spare tire and underseat.

According to my experience, both offer greater sound quality and deep bass but have their advantages and disadvantages.

To help you decide which is better for your needs, I have created a guide so that you can look at the differences between these two types of subwoofers. Let’s begin without wasting any time!

What Are Spare Tire Subwoofers?

Beginning with the spare tire subs! This subwoofer is an enclosed speaker that fits into the spare wheel well in the trunk of your car or SUV. Most of these subs have built-in amplifiers, allowing them to provide deeper bass notes with greater accuracy.

These subwoofers are typically compact in size and specifically engineered to fit within the constraints of the spare tire compartment.

Plus, if you ever need to use your spare tire, you will have to remove this type of subwoofer first – something that isn’t necessary with an underseat model.

Benefits of Spare Tire Subwoofers:

Below, I have mentioned some of the pros of having a spare tire subwoofer in your car:

• Space-Saving Design: Such subwoofers are an excellent choice for people who need to maximize their trunk space. By utilizing the space in the spare tire well in the rear deck, these subwoofers save valuable storage room and don’t sacrifice your audio system’s bass performance. This is especially beneficial for vehicles with limited storage or when you want to keep your trunk free from clutter. You can enjoy deep bass with this subwoofer without sacrificing much-needed cargo space.
• Discreet Installation: The subwoofer is designed to fit into the spare tire well (present in the rear deck), making it hidden from sight and giving your car’s interior a clean and seamless look. This eliminates the need for custom enclosures or visible subwoofer boxes, giving you an aesthetically pleasing sound system while keeping it discreetly tucked away within your car. With discreet installation, you can enjoy great-quality sound without compromising the style and design of your ride.
• Enhanced Bass Performance: The bass will be more profound if I compare the spare tire subwoofers with the underseat subs. They can handle low-end frequencies more precisely than other subwoofers, providing a full range, rich sound, and deep bass response. This can significantly enhance the impact and clarity of the overall audio system in your vehicle. Furthermore, their dedicated design ensures improved performance over traditional subs while also allowing for easy installation in the spare tire well of most vehicles.
• Easy Installation: According to my experience, one of the main advantages is how easy they are to install. Unlike custom enclosure setups, such subwoofers have a specific design and fitment for the spare tire well, making the installation process straightforward. Most brands provide detailed instructions and mounting hardware, allowing even novice car owners to complete the installation quickly. This ease of installation makes them an excellent option for anyone looking to add thumping bass to their ride.
• Versatile Compatibility: Almost every car has a spare tire well in the trunk (rear deck), enabling it to work with a wide range of makes and models, allowing car audio enthusiasts to enjoy the enhanced bass performance in their vehicles. This level of flexibility also means that drivers can switch out their subwoofers when they change cars without worrying about whether they will be compatible. This compatibility also ensures that all users have access to superior sound quality regardless of what type of vehicle they own.
• Retention of Spare Tire: Not only does it improve audio quality, but it also keeps the functionality of your spare tire intact. It’s a handy feature as it keeps you prepared in emergencies since you can still access and use the spare tire without sacrificing sound quality. Retaining your spare tire ensures you maintain safety features while enjoying a better audio performance from your vehicle.

Drawbacks of Spare Tire Subwoofers:

Here are some drawbacks of having such subwoofers:

• Limited Bass Performance: Due to their small size, they cannot achieve the same level of low-frequency response or deep bass that larger subs can. This limits their ability to handle lower frequencies and produces strong bass notes, so they may not offer as powerful a sound as traditional larger subs. However, they still provide solid performance compared to underseat subwoofers.
• Power Handling: If you intend to achieve high sound levels or intense bass output, these subwoofers may not suit your needs. They are simply not designed to handle higher power levels and may struggle with the level of input they receive from more powerful audio systems.
• Price Range: While some models may be more expensive than underseat subwoofers, they may still not match up to full-size subwoofers regarding features and sound quality.

So, Are Spare Tire Subwoofers Any Good for You?

Spare tire subwoofers can be an excellent option for anyone looking to save space and enjoy an improved bass performance from their car audio system.

They offer enhanced sound quality compared to factory speakers and are discreetly installed, preserving trunk functionality. They may have a deep bass response than the underseat subwoofers.

What are Underseat Subwoofers?

Underseat subs are specifically engineered to fit in the available space beneath the vehicle seats, allowing discreet installation without other trunk or aesthetic disruptions.

Despite their small size, underseat subwoofers offer impressive bass performance that can surpass factory-installed speakers. The low-frequency sound reproduction from these subwoofers gives richness and depth to enhance any audio experience in your car.

Advantages of Underseat Subwoofers:

Here are some of the benefits that you can get from underseat subs:

• Space Efficiency: Like spare tire subs, underseat subwoofers are also a great space-saving option as they fit underneath the seats in the cabin. Utilizing this area that would have otherwise gone unused frees up trunk space for other uses or makes it more accessible for those with small cars.
• Discreet Installation: The discreet installation allows these subs to remain hidden beneath the seats, providing powerful bass performance without disrupting the look of your vehicle. This makes them a perfect solution for those who want their audio system to look as good as it sounds.
• Enhanced Bass Response: These subs provide listeners with a more immersive audio experience, as the bass can reach greater depths due to the improved response. Additionally, underseat subwoofers don’t need additional space or installation compared to larger subs – simply plug in and enjoy.
• Convenience and Versatility: Underseat subwoofers also offer comfort and versatility in their installation as they do not require custom enclosures or additional modifications to the vehicle’s interior. This makes them suitable for many cars, such as sedans, hatchbacks, and SUVs.

Disadvantages of Underseat Subwoofers:

Here are some of the disadvantages of underseat subs:

• Limited Bass Output: Underseat subwoofers have limited bass output compared to larger traditional subwoofers due to their lightweight and compact design. This limitation affects the low-frequency response and deep bass that underseat subs can deliver, meaning they cannot provide the same level of audio quality as larger ones with more air displacement capabilities.
• Installation Constraints: These subs may be challenging to install due to the limited space under the seats. Furthermore, some models need extra wiring and connections to an external amplifier, which adds complexity and makes installation even more difficult.

Are Underseat Subs Any Good for You?

Yes, underseat subs can be a great addition to your audio system. They provide extra bass and depth of sound that will make your music even better.

Underseat subs are also very easy to install and require minimal setup compared to other car speakers. If you want to upgrade your car audio system without breaking the bank, then an underseat subwoofer is a great option.

Comparing the Spare Tire Subwoofer With Underseat Subwoofer:

Let’s get to the real deal!

1. Sound Performance:

When it comes to bass response, the larger size of an underseat subwoofer makes a big difference. The increased air displacement allows the driver to reproduce frequencies (low) with greater accuracy and depth than its smaller counterpart, adding punch and impact to your listening experience.

Additionally, underseat subs often perform better regarding sound quality; they are designed for precision reproducing low frequencies, resulting in enhanced clarity and detail that provides a sense of immersion into the music.

When you look at power handling capabilities, however, this is where spare tire subs have an advantage over their larger counterparts since they can handle higher power levels without distortion or clipping despite their limited design space.

This means that they still offer powerful bass performance at maximum volumes – but may not reach the same level as an underseat subwoofer due to their reduced size compared with more traditional drivers.

2. Installation and Space Requirements:

As mentioned above, spare tire subwoofers are specifically designed to fit a vehicle’s spare tire well, making them highly convenient for integrated installations.

On the other hand, underseat subwoofers are designed to place underneath a vehicle’s seats, allowing for discreet placement that doesn’t interfere with the interior aesthetics.

Regarding space requirements, spare tire subwoofers require a spare tire well installed without taking additional space from your trunk or occupying any more room than necessary.

Underseat subwoofers, however, offer an advantage to vehicles with limited trunk space. They can comfortably utilize available cabin space beneath the seats while leaving your trunk free for other purposes such as storage or extra seating.

3. Price & Value:

In terms of price, underseat subwoofers tend to be more affordable compared to spare tire subwoofers. Underseats come as pre-designed units with integrated enclosures, while most spare tire subs require additional components such as amplifiers or power supplies, resulting in a higher overall price range.

But the actual value of either type of subwoofer depends on individual preferences and requirements. Spare tire subs provide a space-saving solution without occupying any additional trunk space, making them valuable for those who prioritize trunk storage or have limited space for a traditional enclosure.

On the other hand, some of my clients have found that an underseat unit offers superior performance due to its proximity to the driver’s seat, which allows for better sound quality since sound waves can travel freely around interior surfaces like doors instead of being confined inside the car’s cabin walls or trunk area.

Table Overview Between Spare Tire Sub & Underseat Subwoofer:

Here’s my easy-to-understand comparison table:

Key Features	Spare Tire Subwoofer	Underseat Subwoofer
Sound Quality	Good, but may lack depth	Decent, but limited bass
Installation	Easy to install	Relatively easy to install
Space Requirements	Minimal space required	Fits under the seat
Power Handling	Moderate power handling	Limited power handling
Amplification Options	Requires external amp	Built-in amplifier
Design and Aesthetics	Discreet and hidden	Blends with interior
Price	Mid-range to high	Mid-range to low
Value for Money	Suitable for specific needs	Budget-friendly option

General FAQs